Hah. What an epic twist at the end. I tip my hypothetical plagiaristic hat to you, Mr. Lethem. Through out this entire essay I was thinking, yes, this guy makes some good points, but they are a bit lost because the entire structure is a bit nonsensical. But I completely forgive him, even though it makes commenting on the many points he makes (or is it really him that makes them?) a bit difficult.
Here is what was going on in my mind: Firstly, I liked that the MPAA “You wouldn’t steal a handbag advertisement!” ad was mentioned, because frankly, if I could download a car, I would do it. Secondly, I’m not entirely convinced with the gift economy theory as it applied to original work. A gift implies that I do not get anything tangible in return, which, in this consumer culture, means that there will be no economic incentive to create. In turn, it also means that if everything is a gift, the concept of “worth” will be eliminated, which means that there will be no distinction between what is good and what is bad. This does not present a good outcome. Finally, I feel like it’s just a matter of time until the old corporate Disney-esque generation will die out, and the newer generation that is more acquainted with remix culture will control the copyright patents, and will be more lenient with them.